21.12 – Jeff Davis 18

EPISODE 1211A

Host Aisha Tyler with Wayne Brady, Jeff Davis, Colin Mochrie, Ryan Stiles, Laura Hall and Linda Taylor accompanying.

LET’S MAKE A DATE – Jeff is appearing on a dating show, Wayne is an entire bachelorette party getting out of hand, Colin is a scientist trying to work out which body part if the most ticklish, and Ryan is a pigeon going through a busy day.

SUPERHEROES – The crisis is an earthquake with Colin as Captain Road Rage, Wayne as Fashion Model Man, Jeff as Sticks to Everything Man, and Ryan as Incredible Mr. Nipple Tweak.

NEWSFLASH – Jeff, Colin and Wayne are in the study with Ryan in the field reporting on horror movie clips.

SCENES FROM A HAT – Scenes include unlikely elementary school science presentations, things you shouldn’t do with a loved one’s ashes, and things you can say when shopping that you can’t say about your partner.

GREATEST HITS – Ryan and Colin introduce songs of the butcher sung by Wayne and Jeff, including “Serving Number 10” (opera).

CREDITS – Ryan and Jeff read the credits with the others as though they are speed dating and their date is the camera.

Taped: January 21, 2023      Sister Shows: 21.4, 21.5

21.11 – Kaila Mullady

EPISODE 1222

Host Aisha Tyler with Wayne Brady, Jonathan Mangum, Colin Mochrie, Ryan Stiles, Laura Hall and Linda Taylor accompanying, and special guest Kaila Mullady.

WEIRD NEWSCASTERS – Colin is the anchor, Jonathan is the co-anchor and is a male stripper hired for Colin’s birthday, Ryan is doing sports and is God going through a busy day, and Wayne is doing the weather and is acting out a Transformers movie in 30 seconds.

DUET – Wayne and Jonathan sing with Kaila in the style of hip hop.

SCENES FROM A HAT – Scenes include things you want to get off your chest to the camera, unlikely commercials for cleaning products, if insects could talk, and things you don’t want to hear just as the general anesthesia kicks in.

GREATEST HITS – Ryan and Colin introduce songs of the candy striper sung by Wayne and Jonathan, including “Celebrity Patient” (rock band breaking up during the song) and “Obamacare” (ska/punk).

CREDITS – Jonathan reads the credits with the others as though they are trying on new clothes and the camera is the mirror.

Taped: February 1, 2023      Sister Shows: 21.1, 21.2

21.10 – Chris Lee

EPISODE 1215

Host Aisha Tyler with Wayne Brady, Greg Proops, Colin Mochrie, Ryan Stiles, Laura Hall and Linda Taylor accompanying, and special guest Chris Lee.

LET’S MAKE A DATE – Greg is appearing on a dating show, Wayne is a detective who uses his butt to look for clues, Colin is an alien turned on by big things, and Ryan is the world’s trashiest fairy godmother.

MIXED MESSAGES – Colin has disturbed King Kong and is trying to escape Kong Island with his companions Greg and Wayne, who can only speak using text messages from the phones of Allison and Jordan from the audience.

PROPS – Chris, Wayne and Colin vs. Ryan and Greg.

DOO-WOP – Wayne, Ryan and Colin sing a doo-wop song about Mia who died tragically in a gas station related accident.

LIVING SCENERY – Ryan and Colin are a young couple kayaking through the Bayou before staying the night in Louisiana’s most luxurious hotel casino. Wayne and Chris are the props.

CREDITS – All four read the credits with Chris as Broadway stars performing the end song of Whose Line the Musical.

Taped: January 26, 2023      Sister Shows: 21.3, 21.7

21.9 – Gary Anthony Williams 14

EPISODE 1219

Host Aisha Tyler with Wayne Brady, Gary Anthony Williams, Colin Mochrie, Ryan Stiles, Laura Hall and Linda Taylor accompanying.

HOLLYWOOD DIRECTOR – Ryan and Wayne are two explorers in a booby-trapped tomb. Suddenly they are attacked by an angry demon, Colin. Gary directs them in the styles of attached to strong rubber bands, uncontrollably aroused, and West Side Story.

SOUND EFFECTS – Ryan and Colin are two guys on safari with their wives when they are abducted by aliens. Ashley and Dawn from the audience provide the sound effects.

SCENES FROM A HAT – Scenes include if famous TV shows were preformed by incredibly horny people, if people behaved like video game characters in their everyday lives, and bad times to mimic someone.

GREATEST HITS – Ryan and Colin introduce songs of the podiatrist sung by Wayne and Gary, including “Since the Time I Scraped Your Feet” (Motown love song) and “Remove Your Damn Socks” (Hip Hop).

CREDITS – All four read the credits as if Colin has been bitten by a snake and is pleading with the rest to suck out the poison.

Taped: January 29, 2023     Sister Shows: 21.6, 21.8

21.8 – Mark Ballas

EPISODE 1218

Host Aisha Tyler with Wayne Brady, Gary Anthony Williams, Colin Mochrie, Ryan Stiles, Laura Hall and Linda Taylor accompanying, and special guest Mark Ballas.

WEIRD NEWSCASTERS – Colin is the anchor, Gary is the co-anchor and is Colin’s grouchy grandmother complaining about her ailments, Ryan is doing the sports and is acting out great inventions through human history, and Wayne is presenting the weather as a powerful rock opera.

DELETED SCENES – All four come up with deleted scenes from the movies Jurassic Park and James Bond.

DUET – Wayne and Mark sing a duet in the style of a Broadway musical.

PROPS – Wayne and Colin vs. Ryan and Gary.

LIVING SCENERY – Ryan and Colin are traveling on a luxurious private jet when it crashes in the jungle and they have to use what they can find to survive. Wayne and Mark stand in as the props.

SCENES FROM A HAT – Scenes include bad people to go on vacation with, and unusual parts of the body to sing a love song about.

CREDITS – All four read the credits with Mark as finalists of the air guitar championships.

Taped: January 29, 2023      Sister Shows: 21.6, 21.9

21.7 – Greg Proops 10

EPISODE 1216

Host Aisha Tyler with Wayne Brady, Greg Proops, Colin Mochrie, Ryan Stiles, Laura Hall and Linda Taylor accompanying.

QUESTIONS WITH HATS – The scene is passions erupt at a billionaire’s wedding.

SCENES FROM A HAT – Scenes include if Sesame Street dealt with adult problems, and things you should never brag about.

WHOSE LINE – The scene is Samson (Colin) has woken up to discover his lover Delilah (Ryan) has cut off his hair.

FILM DUB – All four dub the scene “one day in a restaurant”.

GREATEST HITS – Greg and Colin introduce songs of the exterminator sung by Wayne and Ryan, including “Snake Up My Pant Leg” (Simon and Garfunkel) and “Spider Nest in Your Hair” (Lil Wayne and John Wayne).

CREDITS – All four read the credits taking turns to bitch about the others into the camera.

Taped: January 26, 2023      Sister Shows: 21.3, 21.10

21.6 – Alyson Hannigan

EPISODE 1213

Host Aisha Tyler with Wayne Brady, Gary Anthony Williams, Colin Mochrie, Ryan Stiles, Laura Hall and Linda Taylor accompanying, and special guest Alyson Hannigan.

QUESTIONS WITH HATS – The scene is passions erupt in a swanky cocktail bar.

DOO-WOP – Wayne, Gary and Colin sing about Melissa who died tragically in an amusement park related accident.

DUBBING – Teenage sweethearts, Wayne and Alyson, are rehearsing a song for their high school musical, when suddenly school bully Colin arrives and demands the main part. Ryan provides the voice for Alyson.

SCENES FROM A HAT – Scenes include superheroes in old age, when a big hug is not appropriate, and unusually parts of the body to sing a love song about.

HELPING HANDS – Ryan is running a German-themed food stall when his ex-girlfriend Alyson arrives. Colin provides the hands for Ryan.

CREDITS – All four read the credits with Alyson as high schools at band camp rehearsing for a concert.

Taped: January 29, 2023      Sister Shows: 21.8, 21.9

21.5 – Jeff Davis 17

EPISODE 1213

Host Aisha Tyler with Wayne Brady, Jeff Davis, Colin Mochrie, Ryan Stiles, Laura Hall and Linda Taylor accompanying.

HOLLYWOOD DIRECTOR – The scene is Ryan and Jeff are two bickering little pigs, when suddenly big bad wolf Wayne enters. Colin directs them in the styles of sleazy reality show, movie stars, and Cabaret.

SCENES FROM A HAT – Scenes include the world’s least sexy phone sex lines, street performers you’d never give money to, and unlikely first lines of Christmas songs.

SOUND EFFECTS – The scene is Ryan and Colin are parents taking their family on a camping trip where things keep going terribly wrong. Nancy and Jasmine from the audience provide the sound effects.

DOO-WOP – Ryan, Jeff and Colin sing about Kelly who died tragically in an Olympics accident.

LIVING SCENERY – Billionaire Wayne and his new bride Ryan are traveling around the world using as many different modes of transport as possible. Colin and Aisha are the props.

CREDITS – Wayne and Jeff read the credits with Ryan and Colin as bitchy makeup artists giving the camera a makeover.

Taped: January 21, 2023      Sister Show: 21.4, 21.12

21.4 – Maile Brady

EPISODE 1212

Host Aisha Tyler with Wayne Brady, Jeff Davis, Colin Mochrie, Ryan Stiles, Laura Hall and Linda Taylor accompanying, and special guest Maile Brady.

PRESS CONFERENCE – Colin is announcing that he’s slept with all of the Muppets with Ryan, Jeff and Wayne as reporters.

DUET – Wayne sings to Maile Brady in the style of R&B.

MIXED MESSAGES – Colin is the captain of a space ship that is getting sucked into a black hole and summons his crewmen Wayne and Jeff to figure out what to do. Wayne and Jeff can only speak using text messages from Charlie and Tatum’s phones from the audience.

PROPS – Wayne, Colin and Maile vs. Ryan and Jeff.

FILM DUB – All four dub the film An Evening Gone Wrong.

DUBBING – Influencers Wayne and Maile are trying to perfect a song and dance routine for TikTok. Colin is the rival TikTok-er challenging them to a dance off. Ryan provides the voice for Maile.

CREDITS – Wayne reads the credits with Maile as choreographers trying teach some moves to the world’s least sexy dancers, Ryan, Colin and Jeff.

Taped: January 21, 2023      Sister Shows: 21.5, 21.12

21.3 – Jordin Sparks

EPISODE 1214

Host Aisha Tyler with Wayne Brady, Greg Proops, Colin Mochrie, Ryan Stiles, Laura Hall and Linda Taylor accompanying, and special guest Jordin Sparks.

WEIRD NEWSCASTERS – Greg is the anchor, Colin is the co-anchor and is a candy maker demonstrating his new product the Greg Lollipop, Ryan is the sportscaster and is the movie Titanic in 30 seconds, and Wayne is doing the weather and is acting out the Bible.

SONG STYLES – Wayne sings to Jordin Sparks in the style of an R&B duet.

SCENES FROM A HAT – Scenes include pickup lines in Star Trek, weird categories at the Academy Awards, and things you can say that are guaranteed to end a relationship.

HELPING HANDS – Ryan is the charismatic owner of a health food cafe taking his girlfriend Jordin through the menu. Colin provides the hands for Ryan.

CREDITS – Greg and Wayne read the credits with Jordin as bad tempered teens arguing with their parents Ryan and Colin.

Taped: January 26, 2023      Sister Shows: 21.7, 21.10